CHOMP
Nothing Hard,
Nothing Sticky,
Nothing Chewy

BRUSH
Keeping It Clean

PLASTICS
Your Appliances

EAT
The Cookie Lady's Recipe Box

JOIN
Sign up for the Dr. Malerman Mailing List, get braces-friendly recipes and photos

CALL
Is something loose or broken? Need an appointment?

VIEW
Take a tour of the treatment area and the records room.

The Orthodontist's Shepherd's Pie

How is it possible we did not think of Shepherd's Pie before this? Well, this really is not an orthodox Shepherd's Pie but our fearless leader liked it even on the first try. It is easy to chew and it has lots of vegetables and protein; it is all hidden under a ton of cheesy potatoes, really good.

This recipe makes a huge finished product so it is easy to make one Shepherd's Pie for the freezer, without the topping on to serve.

Please read the entire recipe all the way through before you start.

Prepare the base

Chop about the same size (roughly ½" - ¼" dice):

  • 2 c. onions
  • 1½ c. celery
  • 2 c. carrots

Sauté, in a very large frying pan or wide pot, in 3 Tbsp. olive oil. Sauté 3 to 4 minutes, until the celery looks even brighter green.

Add to the hot pot:

  • 2 lbs. ground beef

Cook over medium heat until the vegetables are limp and the meat is brown. Then add to the pan:

  • 3 Tbsp. all-purpose or Wondra flour

Cook 3 to 4 minutes to get rid of the floury pasty taste of raw flour.

Add and stir in until very well combined and starting to thicken:

  • 2 to 3 c. chicken broth (note: warmed chicken broth mixes in more easily than cold)

Prepare the sauce

At this point add:

  • 1 tsp. dried thyme, crumbled
  • ½ tsp. dried rosemary, crumbled
  • 1 tsp. salt
  • ½ tsp. garlic powder
  • ¼ to ½ fresh ground pepper
  • 3 Tbsp. ketchup
  • 1 Tbsp. Worcestershire sauce
  • 1½ c. frozen peas
  • 1½ c. frozen corn

Cook about 5 minutes at a simmer. Taste for salt and pepper. Set aside. If you are cooking this ahead, chill the mixture at this point. See notes.

Prepare the topping

Preheat the oven to 375°. Then cook

  • 4½ lbs. potatoes (I used Yukon Gold but russets are fine too.)

Cook in salted water until very tender.

While potatoes cook, grate cheeses:

  • 1½ c. Swiss or Jarlsberg cheese
  • 1½ c. Parmesan cheese
  • 1½ c. half and half, heated steaming hot but not boiling.

Drain potatoes very well, return to hot pot and whip in (by hand or mixer) the cheeses, half and half along with salt and pepper to taste. Spread the potatoes over the top of the meat mixture in two pie plates.

Sprinkle with:

  • Paprika
  • 2 Tbsp. (total) butter cut into tiny pieces

Bake on a cookie sheet, because it will drip, for 45 minutes at 375°. If the meat mixture is cold, bake 15 minutes longer.

This recipe makes two 9 or 10 inch pies. It should serve 8 to 10 people.

Notes:

  1. I made 10 individual portions in au gratin dishes that I lined with two layers of plastic wrap. Freeze, then place each inside freezer bags, labeled clearly and dated and you can still use your au gratin dishes until you are ready to thaw the pies for dinner. Spray the dish with vegetable spray, place unwrapped filling in the dish, allow to thaw or thaw in microwave oven and continue with topping and baking.
  2. If you prefer, you can use meatloaf mix or ground turkey, a mixture of them or ground lamb instead of beef.
  3. You are not tied to the herbs the Cookie Lady used here. Herbs de Provence, Italian herb mixture or any you prefer are fine.
  4. There is no set mix of vegetables that must be used in Shepherd's Pie. Some have green beans, eggplant, chopped tomatoes, mushrooms or anything you like that can stand up to being cooked twice.
  5. A Cookie Lady Recipe

    copyright drmalerman.com, 1999 - 2014

    Stay in touch: e-mail us at molarman@drmalerman.com,
    or call 215-643-0778.

    Get braces-friendly recipes, photos and info! Sign up for the DrMalerman.com mailing list today by going to this page and following the simple directions.